KPMG Law LLP logo

17 November 2026

On 21 September 2026, the Irish Financial Services Appeals Tribunal (“IFSAT”) delivered its decision in an appeal by former Permanent TSB (“PTSB”) chief executive David Guinane (“Mr Guinane”) against a Central Bank of Ireland (“CBI”) Inquiry Decision finding that he had participated in PTSB’s regulatory contravention concerning the treatment of certain tracker mortgage customers during the financial crisis.

The Inquiry had resulted in an €80,000 fine and a reprimand under section 33AQ of the Central Bank Act 1942, as amended (the “1942 Act”). which provides for a range of sanctions against persons found to have participated in a regulatory contravention.

Following a hearing, IFSAT recommended that Mr Guinane’s appeal be allowed and that the finding against him be dismissed.

Overview

The proceedings arose from the CBI’s investigation into PTSB’s treatment of certain tracker mortgage customers during the financial crisis. The CBI subsequently pursued an Inquiry under its Administrative Sanctions Procedure (“ASP”) into whether Mr Guinane, as chief executive of PTSB, had personally participated in PTSB’s regulatory contravention.

Following the Inquiry Member’s finding that he had participated in the contravention, Mr Guinane appealed the Inquiry Decision to IFSAT. A central issue on appeal was the Inquiry Member’s approach to “participation” and, in particular, whether the basis on which Mr Guinane was ultimately found to have participated in PTSB’s contravention went beyond the allegation he had been required to meet. IFSAT found fundamental legal and procedural defects in the Inquiry Decision, which led to the decision on 21 September.

Background

The underlying contravention concerned PTSB’s treatment of certain customers who had moved from tracker to fixed interest rates and their entitlement to return to a tracker rate.

Mr Guinane was PTSB’s chief executive during the relevant period and the CBI proceeded with the case based on his involvement in the bank’s consideration of the position of the affected customers. Some of the evidence purported by the Inquiry included communications between Mr Guinane and other PTSB personnel concerning the tracker mortgage issue. The question for the Inquiry was therefore not simply whether PTSB had committed a regulatory contravention, but whether Mr Guinane’s own conduct amounted to “participation” in that contravention.

An important issue arose as to the basis on which that participation could be established. In reaching his decision, the Inquiry Member relied on concepts of negligence, carelessness and recklessness in his consideration of Mr Guinane’s conduct. This became significant because the original allegation notified to Mr Guinane had not been framed on the basis that he had participated in PTSB’s contravention through negligent or careless conduct. Accordingly, whether he had been given fair notice of the case he was required to meet became a central issue before IFSAT.

Following the inquiry under the ASP, the Inquiry Member determined that the allegation against Mr Guinane had been established and imposed a reprimand and a financial penalty of €80,000. Mr Guinane appealed the Inquiry Decision to IFSAT under Part VIIA of the 1942 Act.

The Tribunal’s decision

IFSAT considered both the allegation set out in the Notice of Inquiry and the Inquiry Member’s approach to the meaning of “participation”. A key issue was whether the Inquiry Member had departed from the case that Mr Guinane had been given notice of, and was required to answer, by relying on negligence, carelessness, or recklessness in reaching his finding of participation.

The Tribunal concluded that the Inquiry Member had erred in law and acted ultra vires and unreasonably. It also identified failures to give fair notice of certain issues and to provide adequate reasons for the decision. It found that the errors of law were sufficiently fundamental to undermine the basis of the Inquiry Decision.

Under section 57Z(2)(c) of the 1942 Act, IFSAT is empowered to substitute an appropriate decision that the CBI could lawfully have made at the Inquiry. It therefore recommended that the appeal be allowed and the allegation against Mr Guinane dismissed.

High Court confirmation

In a supplemental decision, IFSAT considered the publication of its substantive decision, High Court confirmation and costs.

The CBI argued that High Court confirmation was unnecessary because IFSAT’s substituted decision contained no adverse finding or sanction against Mr Guinane, however, IFSAT concluded that the substantive decision remained subject to confirmation by the High Court.

The High Court has now confirmed IFSAT’s decision, thereby giving effect to the Tribunal’s recommendation that Mr Guinane’s appeal be allowed and the allegation against him dismissed.

Outcome and implications

The decision highlights the procedural safeguards that apply to individuals subject to the CBI’s ASP, particularly the need to identify clearly the case they are required to meet, give fair notice of the matters relied upon and provide adequate reasons for any finding of participation in a firm’s regulatory contravention.

The decision also demonstrates the potential significance of how an allegation of participation is framed. Where an inquiry ultimately relies on a different basis for establishing participation, including concepts such as negligence or carelessness that were not part of the case notified to the individual, issues of fair notice and fair procedures may arise.

The decision follows Central Bank of Ireland v CD [2026] IEHC 203, another recent case concerning procedural fairness in the context of CBI enforcement proceedings. Both decisions demonstrate the importance of fair procedures where regulatory action is taken against individuals.

How KPMG Law can help

Any party involved in a CBI investigation or enforcement action should approach the process with an understanding of the relevant legal issues, including the principles of natural justice and fair procedures, and with appropriate professional support.

Experienced lawyers from KPMG Law LLP’s Financial Services Regulation team can provide firms and individuals with confidential legal advice in relation to regulatory investigations and enforcement matters.

Contact our team

Nicola Munnelly

Nicola Munnelly

Director, Financial Services Regulation

Derek Hegarty

Derek Hegarty

Partner, Head of Financial Services and Dispute Resolution

Discover more in Financial Services Regulation